Retweet. A Twitter FAIL
If you tweet, you’ll have noticed that Twitter has a new retweet feature where instead of having to copy/paste someone’s tweet and add an ‘RT’ in front of their name, you can just click the little button and it does all that for you.
Sounds great… and many people are using it, only many of those people don’t realize one important factor.
When someone retweets your tweet using that new button, you don’t get notified of it with a comeback in your @ timeline, allowing you to thank the people who are retweeting your tweet and exposing you to their follower list, potentially gaining you some new followers.
I think that’s rude, and so far, it causes twits like me a lot of extra work in opening up another window/tab for Twitter search, searching my own Twitter handle and then having to go through the list of results looking for any retweets I didn’t know about… then tweeting my thanks.
I’ve been tweeting this, hoping to make others aware, but worry perhaps that too, is starting to annoy some. I’ve sent this concern in to the twitter gurus via their feedback, and am sharing it with you too. Perhaps you didn’t realize this? Perhaps you’d also like to ask the folks behind the scenes at Twitter to fix this.
Here is my feedback, verbatim:
The new retweet feature is more convenient to use, but awful. The retweet does not show up in the @ timeline of the person they’ve retweeted, so that person doesn’t know they’ve been retweeted unless they go to twitter search and search their own twitter handle and then go through the list to find any retweets. In other words… the majority of people being retweeted never know it and can’t thank the person who retweeted them. This makes for poor relations with your followers, and because most people don’t realize this… they will simply think we are rude for not tweeting a thanks every now and then.
I think that’s a HORRID oversight. So now, instead of making retweeting easier, which I’m sure was the intent, you’ve made a more onerous task of it because I have to go somewhere else (twitter search) and find all my retweets instead of just viewing my @’s.
Please fix that.
As I tweet to raise awareness, so that people don’t think ME rude for not thanking… other followers are getting annoyed because they don’t realize this and just think I’m being a pest.
Good intentions, but it’s a fail.
I’m sure you are getting good responses too… for the convenience I’m sure, but I question if those people realize this other issue… and if they did, would they still give it a positive review?
Don’t get me wrong… I do appreciate, enjoy and love all the benefits of using Twitter. It is a fabulous service, but even those who get it right can have times when they get something wrong. I think this is one of them and if they’re as great as so many of us think… they’ll fix this so that we can all be a little more gracious to the followers who retweet us and help us build our followings. In other words, they’ll retweak the retweet!
So what do you think? Leave your thoughts in the comments!



I didn’t know this about the new RT feature until I read your post. Thanks again. Hey, so maybe the lack of @ for ME is because of the new feature and NOT because nobody loves me? I am not going to do the search, I am just going to “Believe”…
I have a twitter account, but do not use it all that much. Not real sure what the real use of it is yet.
submom – I figured it out by accident and was all, “HEY… this sucks…” They should fix it because so many people probably don’t know and likely get annoyed enough to unfollow people they think are never thanking them for their RT’s. It’s just bad karma that they overlooked that.
LOTGK – I wasn’t sure about it either, but Kevin over at Fuelmyblog seemed to really believe in it, so on New Year’s Day 2009, I decided to become a twit. Raincoaster swears by the traffic it brings to her site and once I started tweeting links to posts I wanted to highlight (not all posts…) I notice that I do get traffic from it. I tweet lots in between links though, because I hate the folks that do nothing on twitter but plug stuff. It’s not meant for that.
I won’t ever have 10K followers, because I try check them out before adding them so lots of the ones that are spam and come by bots don’t get added and lots of times I even block them… but I have enough to make me happy.
You should try adding to your followers and then linking to some of your posts… and see for yourself.
I don’t really care who’s retweeting my tweets… I’m not followed much and don’t really use it to network. But I don’t like it because while it’s easy to get a message out, you can’t add a comment to it or edit it if someone adds a lot of tags that are meaningless to me.
The keyword search annoys me because every word I write is scrutinized. I mentioned looking at old photos at Thanksgiving and had 10 professional photographers following me. I mention something “bugs me” and I get exterminators following me — from all over the country! Amazing thing, this twitter….
@Tazz – I know what you mean. Sometimes that keyword thing drives me batty too… especially when you’re having lighthearted banter with friends and suddenly you’ve got a dozen of those p0rn bats using that icky Brittney photo as their avatar on your follow list. A tweeter on my list was inundated with that the other day.
Of course, what a wonderful site and stuff, I will add in back link in order to discover this specific site Take care, Reader.